Business Immigration Impacts
On January 20, 2025, President Donald Trump began his second term with a staunch America-first agenda aimed at reshaping immigration policies and tightening border controls. These sweeping changes have far-reaching implications for businesses that rely on employment-based immigration.
Are you prepared for these changes?
In this post, I outline the steps businesses must take to adapt and protect their workforce.
Day 1 Implementation
On his first day back in office, President Trump wasted no time rolling out a series of executive orders reflecting his administration’s priorities. Among the most controversial was the order titled Protecting the Meaning and Value of American Citizenship, which seeks to end birthright citizenship for children born in the U.S. to parents holding temporary visa statuses, such as H-1B, H-4, L-1, L-2, F-1 student, and J-1 exchange visitor visas. This policy also extends to children born to individuals under the Visa Waiver Program, B-1/B-2 business and tourist visas, and those with temporary protected status or humanitarian parole.
While children of lawful permanent residents retain their citizenship rights, the order restricts U.S. government agencies from issuing citizenship documents, such as passports, to affected groups. How would your business adapt if this policy impacted your workforce? This directive risks significant disruptions, making it harder for children to access critical benefits, enroll in schools, or obtain identification documents at state and local levels. Although legal challenges have already been filed, resulting in a temporary federal court block on the order’s implementation, the potential consequences remain for impacted families and the employers who rely on their talent.
Other notable Day 1 actions included resuming border wall construction, implementing stricter measures to address visa overstays, and reinstating travel bans on certain countries. Framed as essential for national security and economic protection, these initiatives underscore the administration’s hardline stance on immigration as it begins its second term.
Employment-Based Immigration
The Trump administration has signaled its intent to revisit and tighten employment-based immigration policies, placing a strong emphasis on “merit-based” immigration. Key proposals under consideration include:
Increased Scrutiny of H-1B Visas
Eligibility criteria for H-1B visas are expected to become even stricter, with proposals to raise salary thresholds and implement more rigorous evaluations of employers’ needs. Are you ready for the added challenges of recruiting and retaining global talent under these changes? These measures aim to curb perceived misuse of the program and ensure that only “the best and brightest” are granted access to these visas.
Reduction of Optional Practical Training (OPT)
The administration is also exploring significant limitations on the OPT program, which allows international students to work in the U.S. after graduation. Such restrictions could have a profound impact on industries heavily reliant on tech and STEM talent, reducing the pipeline of skilled workers entering the U.S. workforce.
Green Card Allocations
Discussions are underway to reallocate green cards to favor highly skilled workers by reducing the number available in family-based immigration categories. Does your business have a plan to adjust if these changes affect your long-term staffing needs? This potential shift reflects the administration’s commitment to reshaping immigration priorities to align with its merit-based vision.
How the Tech Industry Will Be Uniquely Impacted
The tech industry is particularly vulnerable to the proposed changes in employment-based immigration policies. As a sector that relies heavily on foreign talent to fill specialized roles in software engineering, data science, artificial intelligence, and other STEM-related fields, even minor disruptions to programs like H-1B and OPT can result in significant consequences.
H-1B Visa Restrictions
The administration’s plans to raise salary thresholds and enforce stricter eligibility requirements for H-1B visas could disproportionately impact tech companies. Early-stage startups and mid-sized firms, in particular, may find it challenging to meet these higher salary standards, leaving them at a disadvantage compared to larger corporations with more resources. This would limit their ability to recruit global talent, stifling growth and innovation in an already competitive market.
Reduction of Optional Practical Training (OPT)
Proposed limitations on the OPT program, which allows international students to work in the U.S. after graduation, could significantly shrink the pipeline of young tech talent entering the workforce. U.S. universities are among the world’s leading producers of tech innovators, and restricting opportunities for these graduates risks losing a generation of skilled workers who would otherwise contribute to groundbreaking technological advancements.
Talent Shortages and Project Delays
Stricter visa policies will inevitably lead to delays in hiring skilled workers, creating project backlogs and slowing innovation cycles. Is your business prepared to navigate project delays caused by limited access to global talent? Industries heavily dependent on cutting-edge technology—such as fintech, cybersecurity, and artificial intelligence—are likely to feel the impact most acutely. Prolonged hiring challenges could hinder the ability of tech companies to deliver on critical projects and remain competitive.
Global Competitiveness
As U.S. immigration policies tighten, countries like Canada, the UK, and Australia are positioning themselves as more welcoming alternatives for tech talent. Could your business be at risk of losing talent to these friendlier markets? This creates a significant risk of a “brain drain,” as skilled workers opt for countries with friendlier immigration policies. This shift could further erode the U.S.’s position as a global leader in technology and innovation.
Given the tech industry’s reliance on highly skilled international talent, tech companies, in particular, must act swiftly to mitigate these risks. Filing petitions early, maintaining rigorous compliance records, and working closely with experienced legal counsel to navigate policy changes are no longer optional—they are essential for staying competitive in this rapidly evolving landscape.
Best Practices for Navigating the New Immigration Challenges
The stakes are even higher now. Increased scrutiny, administrative challenges, and stricter policies are on the horizon. Employers must adopt a proactive, forward-looking approach to protect their workforce and operations. This requires decisive and strategic actions, including the following:
1. Filing Petitions Early
Submitting petitions under current rules is one of the most critical steps employers can take to minimize the risk of denials or delays once new policies take effect. Companies should prioritize this step to ensure that employees maintain valid immigration status, especially as processing times and review scrutiny intensify.
The Trump administration’s first term demonstrated that preparation is critical to minimizing the impact of abrupt policy changes. Employers that acted early—filing petitions, conducting audits, and maintaining compliance—successfully avoided disruptions and talent shortages. Conversely, those that delayed faced significant challenges, including project delays and strained client relationships.
2. Conducting Compliance Audits
Regularly reviewing I-9 records and other compliance documentation is essential for maintaining readiness for inspections. Employers must audit these records to ensure they are complete, accurate, and up to date. Focus on common I-9 errors, such as missing employee or employer signatures, incorrect dates, and mismatched expiration dates between Form I-94 and EADs. Additionally, verify that job titles, salaries, and worksite locations align with the details submitted in visa petitions. Addressing these issues proactively will help avoid potential fines or complications during inspections.
3. Maintaining Documentation
Ensuring that all employee documentation is accurate and complete is no longer optional—it is essential to regulatory compliance. Employers should:
- Verify that all required documentation aligns with current immigration status and entry records.
- Employees should safeguard original documents at home, securely digitize and store backup copies, and maintain certified or notarized copies of key records, including passports, Form I-94 Arrival/Departure Records, Form I-797 approvals, and EADs—to ensure compliance and readiness for inspections
Being prepared to provide vetted copies during routine inspections or surprise audits minimizes the risk of legal complications. For foreign nationals, particularly those on F-1, H-1B, L-1, or other temporary visas, having documentation that matches their most recent entry status is critical to avoiding misinterpretation or unintended overstays.
4. Educating and Supporting Employees
Maintaining valid documentation is a legal requirement, but employees may not always understand the full implications of noncompliance. Employers should take steps to educate their workforce by:
- Encouraging Vigilance: Remind employees to verify their documentation, including passports, I-94 records, and EADs, to ensure accuracy.
- Preparing for Inspections: Train employees on how to present documentation during inspections and audits to avoid unnecessary complications.
- Offering Clear Guidance: Provide employees with clear, actionable guidance on how to maintain compliance, avoid inadvertent errors, and understand their legal responsibilities.
By creating a culture of compliance, employers can build a more resilient and prepared workforce.
5. Aligning Employment Practices with Visa Terms
Employers must ensure that job descriptions, salary levels, and worksite locations align with the details submitted in visa petitions. Any discrepancies between petition details and actual employment conditions can lead to noncompliance, which could jeopardize an employee’s immigration status. Employers should clearly communicate these details to employees and train them to consistently explain their employment terms to immigration or border officials, minimizing risks during inspections or travel.
6. A Forward-Looking Approach
The stakes are higher than ever, and the need for proactive strategies has never been more critical. Employers must adopt a forward-looking approach, leveraging expert legal guidance to stay ahead of policy changes. Filing petitions early, conducting regular compliance audits, and maintaining open communication with employees are no longer optional—they are essential steps to protect talent and ensure operational stability in today’s increasingly complex immigration landscape.
7. Learn from the Past: A Tale of Two Companies
The importance of proactive preparation cannot be overstated. The first Trump administration’s crackdown on immigration created a ripple effect of uncertainty, and businesses that prepared early emerged far more resilient.
During the first Trump administration, my law firm’s immigration team worked with a mid-sized tech company that avoided major disruptions by acting early. Anticipating stricter H-1B scrutiny, they filed all extension petitions six months in advance, conducted internal compliance audits, and maintained robust documentation for site visits. As a result, the company retained its skilled workforce while competitors struggled with rejected applications and unexpected audits.
In contrast, a small consulting firm delayed acting, assuming their existing H-1B approvals would suffice. When stricter policies were implemented, the firm was caught off guard during surprise site visits. Incomplete compliance records and discrepancies between petition details and employees’ actual work led to denied H-1B extensions. This resulted in project delays, strained client relationships, and ultimately, lost revenue. By the time the firm addressed these issues, the damage was already done.
These contrasting examples highlight the critical difference preparation can make. Companies that fail to adapt to changing immigration policies risk losing talent, incurring operational disruptions, and facing reputational damage that could take years to repair.
By combining proactive petition filings, rigorous compliance audits, employee education, and strategic planning, employers can safeguard their operations and workforce from the challenges posed by evolving immigration policies.
Preparation Is Essential
Preparation is no longer optional—it is a critical and immediate necessity for businesses navigating shifting immigration policies. Employers that delay action face severe risks: costly legal penalties, disrupted operations, and the loss of vital talent in a competitive market. The stakes are higher than ever, and inaction is simply not an option. By acting now—filing petitions, aligning employment practices, and conducting thorough audits—you can protect your workforce and maintain stability amid these challenges. Don’t let your business fall behind. The time to prepare is now—before it’s too late to mitigate the impact.
The post Trump’s Second Term Immigration Impacts: A Guide for Businesses appeared first on Harris Sliwoski LLP.