The 28th session of the Codex Alimentarius Committee on Food Import and Export Inspection and Certifications Systems (CCFICS28) addressed all the scheduled topics on its agenda. CCFICS28 was incredibly productive as it finalized new and revised internationally recognized guidance on (a) prevention and control of food fraud; (b) principles for the digitalization of national food control systems (NFCS); (c) harmonization of the use, design, implementation and update of establishment lists; and, (d) recognition of equivalence of sanitary measures, technical requirements, an entire NFCS, or only a part of a NFCS. CCFICS also reviewed extensively the draft proposed guidelines on traceability/product tracing within the context of a NFCS, and although it was very close to finalizing them, it will have to consider them again at CCFICS29. CCFICS28 spent significant parts of the meeting to discuss (a) the draft guidance on the standardization of the representation of attestations for official certificates (sanitary requirements); as well as (b) the proposed guidance on appeal mechanisms in the context of rejection of imported food and agreed to send both back for further redrafting in advance to the next session. CCFICS28 agreed to explore possible new future work on principles and guidelines for the use of artificial intelligence and advanced analytical tools in NFCS, for consideration by CCFICS29. Last but not the least, Spain agreed to ensure the update of the Committee’s wish-list for possible future work.1
See more information available about CCFICS28 working documents quoted in this article,2 as well as in the official report of CCFICS28.3 Codex standards, guidelines, codes of practices and related miscellaneous texts quoted in this article are readily and freely available.4
FOOD FRAUD PREVENTION AND CONTROL
CCFICS28 agreed to forward the draft guidelines on the prevention and control of food fraud to the Codex Alimentarius Commission (CAC) for final adoption at its forthcoming session (July 2027) and their subsequent publication as new guidelines.5
CONSOLIDATED GUIDELINES ON EQUIVALENCE
CCFICS28 agreed to (a) forward the draft Principles and guidelines for the recognition of equivalence of sanitary measures, technical requirements, national food control systems (NFCS) or a part of a NFCS to CAC50 for final adoption and subsequent publication as a new consolidated guidelines (see Part 1 of Appendix III in the CCFICS28 report). CCFICS also recommended to CAC50 to revoke the existing Guidelines (i) for the development of equivalence agreements regarding food imports and export inspection and certification systems (CXG 34); (ii) on the judgement of equivalence of sanitary measures associated with food inspection and certification system (CXG 53); and (iii) on the recognition and maintenance of equivalence of national food control systems (NFCS) (CXG 101); with some consequential amendments to CXG 47, CXG 82, CXG 89, and CXG 26 (on the definition of equivalence) and, as appropriate, CXG 60 (see Part 2 of Appendix III in the CCFICS28 report).6
TRACEABILITY/PRODUCT TRACING: REVISION OF EXISTING CXG 60.
CCFICS reviewed the entire text and only a few elements remained in square brackets at the end of the time allocated to this matter. CCFICS28 (a) forwarded the proposed draft revised Principles for traceability / product tracing as a tool within a food inspection and certification system to CAC50 for advancement and requested CCEXEC91 to extend the deadline for completion of the work to CCFICS29 to allow for the resolution of outstanding issues. An EWG led by the United States of America (USA) with the support of Australia and the United Kingdom (UK) was re-established to (i) consider future comments to be received in response to a circular letter when reviewing the outstanding issues left in square brackets in the text as well as consequential changes to the text, noting the entire text remained open for discussion. The possibility of convening virtual and/or PWG meetings was kept open.7
APPEALS MECHANISM IN THE CONTEXT OF REJECTION OF IMPORTED FOOD
CCFICS28 agreed (a) to return the draft guidance on appeals mechanism in the context of rejection of imported food for further consideration by an inter-sessional EWG in advance to the next session and led by India with the support of Australia, Chile, Kenya, Nigeria, Oman and the Philippines to (i) continue drafting the guidance (taking into account the discussions and all the comments made at or in preparation for CCFICS28. The possibility of convening virtual and/or PWG meetings was kept open.8
STANDARDIZATION OF SANITARY REQUIREMENTS: POSSIBLE FUTURE WORK ON REPRESENTATION OF ATTESTATIONS FOR OFFICIAL CERTIFICATES
CCFICS noted the broad support for the objectives of the work and its continuation and in response to the questions posed to the plenary as presented in the relevant Conference Room Document (CRD 04). CCFICS28 agreed that the work should focus on the drafting and representation of attestations in official certificates, covering the full scope of attestations covered by the existing Codex Guidelines for design, production, issuance, and use of generic official certificates (CXG 38), as a future annex to these guidelines. CCFICS28 praised the work done and presented by Brazil and agreed to return the proposed guidance text for further drafting helped informed by the work of an EWG, led by Brazil with the support of Australia, India, Kenya, New Zealand, and Spain tasked to revise the draft guidance on the standardization of the representation of attestations for official certificates (with the intent to make it as a new annex to CXG 38), taking into account discussions and comments made at, and in preparation of, CCFICS28. The possibility of convening virtual meetings and/or a PWG was kept open. CCFICS28 also agreed to inform CCEXEC91 (2027) of the change made to the title of the document as “Guidance on the standardization of the representation of attestations for official certificates”.9
PRINCIPLES AND GUIDELINES TO HARMONISE THE USE, DESIGN, IMPLEMENTATION, AND UPDATE OF ESTABLISHMENT LISTING
CCFICS28 agreed to forward to CAC50 for final adoption the new principles and guidelines to harmonize the use, design, implementation and update of establishment lists, as an annex to the existing Codex Principles and guidelines for the exchange of information between importing and exporting countries to support the trade in food (CXG 89).10
DIGITALIZATION OF NATIONAL FOOD CONTROL SYSTEMS (NFCS): NEW PRINCIPLES AGREED
CCFICS28 agreed to forward the proposed draft principles for digitalization of NFCS to CAC50 for final adoption and inclusion as an Annex to the existing Codex Principles and guidelines for national food control systems (CXG 82) for future publication as its 2027 revised version.11
The FAO representative indicated that the FAO planned to promote cross-border trade, risk-based import inspection and electronic certification, by using digital approaches as appropriate, and, as such, it intended to revise the existing FAO/WHO Food Control System Assessment Tool, which could digitalize the assessment process, and include the examination of digital readiness, data governance and interopera-bility, among other factors. Such a revised tool could then support countries in identifying and prioritizing selected and fit-for-their-purpose investments in digital food control systems. The FAO representative highlighted that these Codex principles would form the basis for that FAO work and she invited Members interested in supporting these efforts to partnering with FAO.12
LIST OF EMERGING GLOBAL ISSUES: REVIEW AND UPDATE OF THE WISH LIST (‘APPENDIX A’)
The European Union introduced the updated ‘Appendix A’, as the volunteered custodian for the item since CCFICS27, and reported that three issues were added to the list based on past comments and discussions held during a ‘workshop’ on (a) the implementation and impact of CCFICS guidance; (b) the challenges for NFCSs in managing food safety hazards arising from emerging risks; and (c) the development of new principles and guidance for the use of artificial intelligence (A.I.) and advanced analytical tools. CCFICS28 expressed its support for the presented updated list, recognized as a useful mechanism for identifying and prioritizing matters that could warrant future work by the Committee. CCFICS28 agreed (a) to keep the list of emerging issues, as identified in the ‘Appendix A’ of the relevant working document (CX/FICS 26/28/11) and keep this item as a standing agenda for the next CCFICS meeting. CCFICS28 agreed with Spain proposal to serve as the new custodian for ‘Appendix A’ further review of a revised list based on comments to be received in response to a new circular letter (CL). The possibility of convening an intersessional workshop was kept open to further discuss emerging issues for possible inclusion into ‘Appendix A’.
DISCUSSION PAPER ON A.I.-SUPPORTED REGULATORY PROCESS USED IN FOOD IMPORT AND EXPORT INSPECTION AND CERTIFICATION SYSTEMS
CCFICS28 noted the following points presented by Spain introducing its discussion paper: (a) A.I. was developing rapidly and could support competent authorities in areas such as risk analysis, inspection planning, document verification, certification and audits; (b) the proposal for the work would not establish separate principles for A.I., but it would examine practical issues arising when A.I. was used in official control procedures and assess the need for guidance to support the consistent application of Codex principles; (c) A.I. should support, but not replace, the responsibility and professional judgement of officials, and safeguards and oversight should be proportionate to the role and degree of autonomy of the technology; and, (d) any future guidance should take into account differences in capacity, infrastructure and resources, and should be flexible, technology-neutral, and be applicable by competent authorities with different levels of “digital maturity”. CCFICS28 noted the relationship between this proposal for new work with the draft principles for the digitalization of NFCSs and its potential practical value for competent authorities. CCFICS28 agreed to establish a new EWG, led by Spain with the support of Australia, Cameroon, Canada, Guatemala, the Philippines, the UK, and Zambia to (i) prepare an updated discussion paper and project document on principles and guidelines for the use of artificial intelligence (A.I.) and other advanced analytical tools in NFCS for consideration at the next session (CCFICS29). The EWG would keep open the possibility of convening virtual and/or PWG meetings, including a PWG immediately before CCFICS29.
Due to lack of time, CCFICS28 was not able to consider the proposal by the UK on piloting the development of a glossary of definitions adopted in CCFICS texts as presented in CRD 18, nor the proposal by the Institute of Food Technologists (IFT) for a new guidance on foundational requirements for digital interoperability within and between national food control systems. CCFICS28 encourages both the UK and IFT to pursue informal discussions with CCFICS members and resubmit their proposals in advance to CCFICS29.
The publication is posted in the October 2026 World Food Regulation Review. Find the full WFRR library here.
ENDNOTES
